Welcome to Brooklyn Brothers Pizza
At Brooklyn Brothers Pizza, our story is one of passion and community. Nestled in Gainesville, VA, we serve up more than just pizza; we create an experience. Our menu boasts a delightful array of pizzas, gyros, and hearty pastas, all crafted with quality ingredients. Diners rave about our flavorful dishes, with particular praise for our pepperoni rolls and rich mushroom ravioli. The welcoming atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for family gatherings or casual dates. Here, you’ll find an unwavering commitment to great food and exceptional service, ensuring that every visit is memorable. Come taste the love we put into every bite!
Brooklyn Brothers Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Pizza/ salad combo was great. Service was great. I'll be back. Cool spot. :)....
OK folks - eating here twice in one week so yes I like this place. Ate here on 1/9/25 - Thursday for lunch. It was pleasantly busy - 8 tables full. Service was good but Sami from my early visit still stands out as a super star. We started with the meatball appetizer- very good and a large portion. Next, I ordered the Jersey Joe hoagie - everything about it was good except the Italian dressing that was drizzled on top - the dressing was sweet and not a good combo with Italian cold cuts - worse for me because I don't like sweet anything. Portion size was large so a good value. Other nit was the pickle - it was soft and not crisp - reminded me of Vlassic which again... not a fan of. Recommend they upgrade to Clausen. My wife had the gyro - same as what she got at our previous visit. It was excellent so they are consistent with the recipe. Net net - really like this place but I need to learn more about their recipes and flavor profiles to dial in on things I like versus the other options.
Well, I have tried pretty much every pizza place in the area and none of them blew my hair back until we tried Brooklyn Brothers. The inside of the restaurant seemed very nice and comfortable. Would be good for a date or a family outing. Getting a pizza was a little bit slow when I ordered in-house but if i order a head they usually have it ready by the time I get there. My only complaint is that they don't offer any specials or discounts, but their pizza is so good I guess they don't need to.
I was about to leave a new review about the consistently great food and service, and then saw 10 years ago I left a review with the same sentiments I still have today. Appreciate Brooklyn Bros. being a reliably great part of our community. Still love the pepperoni rolls and mushroom ravioli and always love the pizza and the welcome atmosphere.
The pizza here is always incredible. Service is quick and friendly. Always greeted as I walk in.
Haven't tried the pizza yet but it looked good. I opted for the meatball sub and a pear and Gorgonzola salad. The salad was very good and filling. The sub was good but the meatballs lacked flavor. I'll definitely try another sub for sure. That is based off the bread. Service was great and it was quiet and clean.
Stopped in on a random Saturday afternoon on my way to the airport because I was feeling some wings. For some reason they had college softball on every tv, nothing wrong with softball but other sports were available Staff was nice, waitress was good, knew the menu, didn't hover. The wings looked good. The sauce needed a little more bite, like some vinegar or something tangy but not terrible. The blue cheese had good chunks in it, so it was good. Overall not a bad experience, food was pricey but not outlandish for the area. I'd go back to try other items on the menu
From the moment you enter this restaurant until the moment you leave you will have a great everything! I'm not sure why we didn't know of this place until recently but now that we found it, that's the only place where we get our pizzas from! People that work there are always kind and helpful. Pizza is always delicious and we are also addicted to their Alfredo and pesto pasta omg soooo good! Strongly recommend this place!
Location
-
8010 Crescent Park Dr, Gainesville, VA 20155 Hotline: (703) 753-6663
Welcome to Brooklyn Brothers Pizza, a slice of New York nestled in the heart of Gainesville, VA. This inviting eatery, located at 8010 Crescent Park Dr, has become a beloved spot for locals craving authentic pizza and hearty heroes. With a casual atmosphere filled with moderate noise, it's the perfect setting for family outings, casual lunches, or simply grabbing a slice with friends.
One of the standout features of Brooklyn Brothers Pizza is their commitment to quality and variety. Their signature pizza pies, such as the Brooklyn Brothers Pizza Pie, boast a delightful medley of meats—including pepperoni, sausage, crispy bacon, ham, and salami—generously topped with shredded mozzarella and their rich pizza sauce. It's a dish that takes you straight to the streets of Brooklyn with every bite.
But the menu doesn't stop there. For those seeking something different, the New York-Style Heroes are a must-try. The Manhattan Club, a triple decker loaded with turkey, ham, crispy bacon, and fresh veggies, exemplifies the hearty offerings that Brooklyn Brothers is renowned for. The Eggplant Parmesan Hero also deserves a mention for its flavor-packed, lightly breaded eggplant, making it a favorite among vegetarian diners.
Customer feedback often highlights not only the delicious food but also the excellent service provided by the staff. A review from Joanna M. perfectly encapsulates the overall experience: "None of them blew my hair back until we tried Brooklyn Brothers." Diners appreciate the warm atmosphere and the attention to guest experience that keeps bringing them back.
Beyond the delectable dishes, Brooklyn Brothers Pizza stands out for its convenience. The restaurant offers delivery and takeout options, allows for reservations, and provides outdoor seating. Whether you're dining in or enjoying your meal at home, the deliciousness of their pizza travels well. Families will be particularly pleased with the generous portions and kid-friendly options, while adults can indulge in their selection of beer and wine.
For those who prefer gathering a group, the restaurant is also open to catering, ensuring that your next celebration is filled with tasty treats. And with free Wi-Fi and bike parking, it caters to all sorts of customers.
In essence, Brooklyn Brothers Pizza is not just about pizza; it’s about community, comfort, and craving that perfectly cooked slice. With their top-notch ingredients, consistent quality, and inviting atmosphere, this restaurant has solidified its place in the hearts of pizza lovers everywhere. Be sure to call ahead at (703) 753-6663 to place your order or to make a reservation. Experience the tastes that keep bringing patrons back for more!
